What You Should Know About Calculating FTR Risk
by Stephanie Staska on May 08, 2023
Have you started looking into trading Financial Transmission Rights (FTRs) and are wondering what you need to know to get started?
FTR transactions are a unique asset class and, as such, have a unique approach to risk management. This post explores challenges relating to calculating FTR risk metrics, and how Yes Energy® can help.
Challenges of Calculating FTR Risk
FTRs are an illiquid product—being traded sometimes only a handful of times in one year in ISO run auctions. These auctions are effectively the only source of price curves available, which leads to a lack of price points to do a traditional VaR calculation.
In order to calculate FTR Risk, you need to use a proxy to calculate a useful risk metric. Finding an effective proxy can be a challenge, especially for a significant historical lookback time period.
Independent System Operator (ISO) Requirement
With the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) Order 741/741A several years ago, it became a requirement to measure risk on your FTR positions. Each year, an officer of your company needs to certify that you have an effective risk policy, which includes quantifying the risk of your FTR portfolio.
For example, in PJM’s Credit Policy, they require that you calculate risk on your FTR positions on no less than a weekly basis. The guidelines provided by PJM related to this risk calculation are that it “engages in a probabilistic assessment of the hypothetical risk of such positions using analytically based methodologies, predicated on the use of industry accepted valuation methodologies.”
"The guidelines provided by PJM related to this risk calculation are that it 'engages in a probabilistic assessment of the hypothetical risk of such positions using analytically based methodologies, predicated on the use of industry accepted valuation methodologies.'”
Independent Calculation of FTR Risk
Depending on the maturity of your organization, you may be relying on a manual risk calculation in a spreadsheet. This comes with the potential that your figures are incorrect. This could be caused by human error, or have even been known to occur due to manipulative behavior (i.e., to hide positions or risk usage).
If you were transacting exchange traded futures and options, these risks would be low. That is because those transactions are cleared through a Futures Commission Merchant (FCM), sometimes known as a “Clearing Agent.” These FCMs produce statements each business day, which include initial margin—a measurement of market risk.
Within most of the ISO markets, this “initial margin” requirement does not exist, leaving you to measure your FTR risk without an independent source.
In order to support calculating FTR risk there is a fair amount of data management that your company needs to support. This includes:
- Trade Capture
- Unlike exchange traded futures and options, there isn’t a single source of truth for these trades. In the US wholesale markets, there are seven ISOs that provide FTR transactions, with seven different interfaces and file types.
- You also need a plan of how to convert multi month periods to monthly buckets to effectively evaluate risk on your portfolio.
- Model Remappings
- ISO markets often remap one node to another. These occur in cases where a node is de-energized, for example. That means you may own an FTR contract with a source or sink node that is no longer traded. Making sure that you can map these to the new node definition when doing risk calculations is critical to ensure accurate values.
- ISO Changes
- The ISOs can change technology requirements. Some recent examples of this were MISO MUI 2.0 and PJM’s digital certificate requirement. If you have internal processes built to communicate with the ISOs to capture your trades and price curves, you need to make updates to ensure your process is not interrupted.
- The ISOs can also make more foundational changes that impact your ability to capture trades and do risk calculations. A recent example of this was the new PJM Peak Types that were added in 2022. Challenges included: how to calculate risk on old peak types after they were retired and how to calculate risk on new peak types as they were introduced.
Yes Energy Can Help!
Yes Energy’s Position Management™ solution provides the nodal power market Middle Office with a turnkey, consolidated solution for oversight of your trading activities. Yes Energy handles the deal capture of your FTR portfolios, and using industry standard FTR risk methodology you can be confident you are getting accurate values for your reporting and ISO certification needs. This is all delivered to your team through automated email reporting, a visual Middle Office dashboard (Figure 1), and easy to integrate data API.
Figure 1: Position Management FTR VaR (Value at Risk) chart
The Position Management FTR risk calculations are intended to provide the following:
- Industry standard risk metrics to manage your FTR positions and meet internal Risk Policy requirements
- ISO requirements to have risk measurement of open FTR transactions
The system allows you to customize your risk metric calculations and seamlessly integrate them in your downstream process. You can:
- Define custom confidence internals, lookback time periods, seasonality, and more
- Easily drill down into the underlying data to quickly identify what is driving your risk calculations
- Directly integrate data into your global risk reporting using API endpoint or Snowflake functions
With Position Management, you have an independent source of FTR risk calculations, lowering the risk of manual mistakes or interference in your risk management processes. The foundation of these risk calculations is Yes Energy’s data management activities, which include trade capture, price capture, model remappings, and inevitable ISO changes.
Click here to learn more about Position Management today, or schedule a demo!
- Industry News & Trends (63)
- Data, Digital Transformation & Data Journey (45)
- Market Events (30)
- Market Driver Alerts - Live Power (22)
- ISO Changes & Expansion (20)
- Renewable Energy (17)
- Energy Storage / Battery Technology (16)
- Power Markets 101 (9)
- Risk Management (7)
- Utilities (7)
- Financial Transmission Rights (5)
- PeopleOps (2)
- Live Power (1)
- June 2023 (1)
- May 2023 (7)
- April 2023 (3)
- March 2023 (3)
- February 2023 (2)
- January 2023 (3)
- December 2022 (2)
- November 2022 (1)
- October 2022 (3)
- September 2022 (5)
- August 2022 (5)
- July 2022 (3)
- June 2022 (3)
- May 2022 (1)
- April 2022 (3)
- March 2022 (3)
- February 2022 (4)
- January 2022 (4)
- December 2021 (2)
- November 2021 (4)
- October 2021 (4)
- September 2021 (4)
- August 2021 (3)
- July 2021 (5)
- June 2021 (5)
- May 2021 (3)
- April 2021 (3)
- March 2021 (4)
- February 2021 (3)
- December 2020 (3)
- November 2020 (4)
- October 2020 (3)
- September 2020 (5)
- August 2020 (2)
- July 2020 (2)
- June 2020 (1)
- May 2020 (9)
- April 2020 (1)
- November 2019 (1)
- August 2019 (2)
- June 2019 (2)
- May 2019 (2)
- January 2019 (1)
- December 2018 (1)